This is a chapter from the book HYPOADRENOCORTICISM, copyrighted by
the Adrenal Metabolic Research Society of the Hypoglycemia Foundation,
Inc., 153 Pawling Avenue, Troy, New York, USA 12180. Upon the deaths of
Dr. Tintera, M.D. in 1969, and later his wife, the Tintera's heirs passed
all the collected papers of the Hypoglycemia Foundation, Inc. to the Hypoglycemia
Association, Inc. (HAI) This has been reproduced here with the permission
of HAI, Inc.
Endocrine Aspects of Ophthalmologic and
Otolaryngologic Allergy
Presented before the 27th Anniversary Program of the
AMERICAN SOCIETY OF OPHTHALMOLOGIC AND
OTOLARYNGOLOGIC ALLERGY
October 25-26, 1969 - Chicago, Illinois
Preparation of this paper has been supported by a grant from the Adrenal
Metabolic Research Society of the Hypoglycemia Foundation, Inc.
SIDNEY SMITH (1771-1845): I am suffering from my old complaint, the hay fever (as it is called). My fear is, perishing by deliquescence: I melt away in nasal and lachrymal profluvia. My remedies are warm pediluvium, cathartics, topical application of watery solution of opium to eyes, ears, and the interior of the nostrils. The membrane is so irritable, that light, dust, contradiction, an absurd remark, the sight of a dissenter, - anything, sets me sneezing: and if I begin sneezing at twelve, I don't leave off till two o'clock, and am heard distinctly in Tauton, when the winds sets that way - a distance of six miles. Turn your mind to this little curse. If consumption is too powerful for physicians, at least they should not suffer themselves to be outwitted by such little upstart disorders as the hay fever.
Letter to Dr. Holland, June 1835.
Dr. Goldman, your President, asked me as an introductory speaker to
pique your curiosity concerning many of the ophthalmological and rhino-otolaryngological
conditions which relate to the whole man and his general chemistry. I feel
that glaucoma, conjunctivitis, rhinitis, asthma, hay fever, Meniere's Disease,
and chronic bronchitis are manifestations of a disturbance of the whole
man rather than specific entities in themselves. They are signs of a basic
chemical derangement which must be taken into consideration if treatment
is to be effective. In my experience these manifestations occur in individuals
who evidence adrenal cortical dysfunction. For the sake of this discussion,
we will speak of these patients as being hypoadrenocortic. The primary
objective in the treatment of hypoadrenocorticism is to achieve a state
of homeostasis involving the endocrine glands, their dependent systems,
and the organism as a whole. Homeostasis implies a balanced harmonious
inter-relationship of the nutritional, endocrine, and nervous aspects of
the organism. The therapeutic purpose, therefore, in endocrinology is to
set up this state of balance and then maintain it.
This is a new era of diagnosis in which we are able to detect inborn
errors of metabolism even at birth. Every chemical action in the body involves
an inherited enzyme system which, in turn, is modulated by hormones. Tests
are rapidly being developed which detect abnormal amounts of amino acids
or other substances including incomplete steroids. Deficiency of an essential
enzyme can also be exposed.
In the infant, eczema of the external auditory canal is not specific
in itself. Bronchitis has a systemic basis. In a normal individual glaucoma
does not occur as a separate disease. The pain of advanced, irreversible
glaucoma is relieved by pilocarpine but it is more rational to relieve
it by helping to restore homeostasis in the victim. Bronchitis has a systemic
basis and may lead to asthma. Meniere's has proved to be a general physiological
disturbance as many investigators have observed.
Adaption (or the lack of it) is an important factor in all physiologic
or pathologic processes. Hence all maladies to some extent involve maladaption
- failure to deal with stress. The ever increasing stress of civilization
is a factor in many ophthalmological and otolaryngological conditions.
IN this context, a nervous breakdown is the inability to adapt to nervous
stress. In our treatment we do not employ tranquilizers or sedatives. As
an adjunct to our program, we balance the autonomic nervous system with
stabilizers, particularly Bellergal.
I am here to demonstrate that an ENT man treats more than specific conditions
mentioned in the texts. I personally know that Dr. Goldman is a specialist
interested in migraine, emotional disturbances, and other conditions such
as anxiety neuroses, which seem far afield from his designated specialty.
No one of you can claim that he treats only eyes, ears or noses.
At the present time Josephson is prescribing breathing and the good
life; nevertheless, he was the first to demonstrate in 1935 that adrenocortical
extract could relieve glaucoma.[2] Sam Roberts, the late Professor Emeritus
of ENT at Kansas State School of Medicine, preached nutrition, and restoring
the individual to as near normal health before attempting to correct a
specific otolaryngologic condition.[3]
There has fortunately been a growing tendency to disregard the limitations
of one's specialty and to visualize the clinical conditions as an end result
dependent upon changes in physiology and body chemistry of the organs of
an organism which is essentially one unified whole.
One of your members, Dr. William D. Currier,[4] in successfully treating
a patient for Meniere's, was challenged by the internist to explain why
he left his specialty to treat a mutual patient for rheumatoid arthritis
which had heretofore been unresponsive to conventional therapy.
For the sake of credibility we have previously stated that about 16%
of the population has some moderate-to-severe degree of hypoadrenocorticism
with hypoglycemia but in actuality, the figure should read 67%, if all
the arthritics, asthmatics and hay fever sufferers, alcoholics and other
related groups are included. Indeed, no family, I believe, actually escapes
the ravages of hypoglycemia resulting from stress induced hypoadrenocorticism.
Even the coronary patient shortly after his attack will have a reactive
hypoglycemia the severity of which depends on the adrenal response to stress.
This reactive hypoglycemia may clear within a few months but it may persist
and later be diagnosed as diabetes or latent diabetes. A sudden drop to
hypoglycemic levels, it has been reported, may produce another coronary
spasm and infarction.
We have observed many interesting physiological and psychological aspects
of the hypoadrenocortic such as pinna ossificans which labels the patient
Addisonian in many endocrinologists' minds. Only as recently as 1967, Henkin
et al., of the National Institute of Health showed that patients with untreated
adrenocortical insufficiency exhibit markedly increased detection sensitivity
of taste and smell. In particular, they found that the auditory threshold
return to normal after administration of adrenal cortical hormones and
ACTH. Desoxycorticosterone decreased the serum potassium level but did
not alter the auditory threshold.[5]
Neither the mechanism of the increased sensitivity to sound nor its
locus of action in the nervous system is known but the phenomenon is not
confined to the auditory system. All three sensory modalities investigated
responded similarly to replacement with carbohydrate active steroids and
in our cases, to ACE.
The olfactory sensitivity in adrenal insufficiency was found to be roughly
100,000 times (1 exp(3) - 1 exp(8) ) more acute than in normal subjects.
Treatment with prednisolone returned the olfactory threshold to normal
in the first day.[6]
In our cases, this sensitivity has been modified by allergic or vasomotor
rhinitis, but with ACE, the extreme sensitivity which often causes nausea
and vomiting, were quickly brought under control. Henkin and Solomon found
an increased taste sensitivity to salt and many other substances in hypoadrenocortic
patients as well as in hypopituitarism.[7]
The controlled testing was done by means of the electrogustometer and
a lowered threshold was found in all of the hypoadrenocortic patients.
Again, moderate doses of prednisone abolished this sensitivity in most
of these patients in 1 to 3 days. The authors recommend that electrogustometry
be used for diagnostic purposes in primary and secondary adrenal cortical
insufficiency.
Allergy
In the course of treating several thousand patients for specifically
an underlying glandular disorder, i.e., adrenocortical dysfunction, a sizable
proportion of these patients presented myriad allergic symptoms. In the
process of correcting the basic glandular dysfunction, it was early noted
that when the general condition improved, the allergic manifestations either
subsided, or entirely cleared up.
In reviewing the patients who presented themselves primarily with allergic
complaints, it was found that in all of them many of the criteria were
present essential for a diagnosis of hypoadrenocorticism relating to ophthalmologic,
rhino-otolargyngologic conditions. Hypoadrenocorticism must be taken to
imply a derangement of many hormones produced by the adrenal gland and
not necessarily be thought of as under-function of the entire-gland. That
is to say, that a disproportion exists among the three groups of adrenocortical
steroids, namely, the glucosteroids, the mineralsteroids, and the 17-ketosteroids.
Most of the patients fit into the picture of hypoadrenocorticism as previously
described elsewhere. [8,15] But indeed, allergic patients have also been
relieved whose diagnosis was adrenocortical hyperplasia, indicating an
overactivity of one zone and a hypofunction of another. When the hypersecreting
cells were inhibited through appropriate hormonal administration, a state
of homeostatis was attained and symptoms alleviate. Carryer and Miller
in a study of 101 patients with Cushing's Syndrome, secondary to adrenal
tumor, or cortical hyperplasia, found two cases with a previous history
of asthma and hay fever. Striking remissions occurred with the development
of Cushing's Syndrome by recurred after surgical extirpation of a major
portion of the functioning adrenal cortex. These men also suggest that
defects in the metabolism of adrenal steroids, congenital or acquired,
may be the basis for the so-called allergic diathesis.[16] It is a reasonable
assumption that adrenocortical dysfunction provides the basis for all allergies
but for practical purposes, we shall assume that there exists a state of
hypofunction of the adrenal cortex involving the zona fasciculata and compromising
carbohydrate metabolism whether the condition is inherited or subsequently
induced by unusual stress.
Generally speaking, most allergies become manifest in their most severe
form following a markedly stressful situation whether it be emotional or
physical. Acute infections, including meningococcic meningitis, puerperal
sepsis, and lobar pneumonia may be associated with necrosis of the adrenal
cortical cells. The probably relationship between adrenal cortical damage
and circulatory collapse in such diseases suggests the use of Eschatin.[17,61]
In a review of the clinical uses of adrenal cortical hormones, references
are made to a specific loss of the cortical factor in overwhelming infections
as being important in shock associated with such conditions.
Perla and Marmorston [62] used cortical hormone as part of the treatment
in severe infections including bronchopneumonia, therapeutic malaria and
severe influenza. This plan of treatment resulted in maintence of normal
blood pressure, decreased signs of toxicity, avoidance of circulatory collapse,
maintence of appetite and shortening of convalescence.
When one or both parents are hypoadrenocortic with allergic manifestations,
a child may be premature and shortly after birth show evidence of adrenal
exhaustion such as electrolyte imbalance, projectile vomiting, eczema or
severe diaper rash. An older individual may not have exhibited any allergic
tendencies until subjected to surgery, emotional shock or other stressful
situations.
Recently, a common more severe form of adrenocortical dysfunction is
encountered in patients who have been treated with individual steroids
for allergies or other unassociated conditions. It is quite obvious how
cortisone or any of its derivatives may upset the intricate hormonal balance
of the cortex by suppression of the zona fasiculata. On the other hand,
the same may be said of ACTH, but this adrenocorticotropic hormone is specific
for cortisone and to a lesser degree for the other cortical components
and thus, the balance of total steroids should be used except in an acute
emergency when a life-saving situation is presented and even then, larger
doses of ACE will usually alleviate the condition without derangement of
the normal balance.
The effects of cortisone, and hydrocortisone include neutrophilia, lymphopenia,
eosinopenia, reticulocytosis, increased gastric secretion, inhibition of
membrane permeability, decreased fibroblastic proliferation, alteration
of immune reactions, alteration of central nervous system excitability
and disturbance of melanin pigmentation.
Cortisone and hydrocortisone have important effects upon carbohydrate,
protein, and fat metabolism. They cause decreased peripheral utilization
of glucose and increased gluconeogenesis from protein. The explains the
decreased tolerance to carbohydrates when excessive cortisone or hydrocortisone
is administered.
Cortisone has been employed empirically for many symptoms common to
hypoadrenocortical patients and as a consequence, the treatment of the
allergic manifestations is further complicated since a state of homeostasis
cannot be attained through the use of the whole adrenal cortex extract
without great difficulty. Indeed, the only failures with ACE therapy have
occurred after indiscriminate use of individual steroids has created an
irreversible situation.
Our concept of disease has been materially augmented by Selye's exposition
of his General Adaptation Syndrome. The allergic patient presents many
of the manifestations described in the general adaptation syndrome including
physical and laboratory findings as described by Selye. The allergic individual
is one who is unable to respond to stress in a normal fashion.
John P. McGovern of Houston, President of the American College of Allergists,
was quoted in the September 9, 1968 issue of "Medical Tribune."
He said in part: "In many asthmatic patients, attacks repeatedly reoccur
or become worse at night, generally between 11 p.m. and 4 a.m. a time coinciding
with minimum excretions of urinary corticoids. These manifestations suggest
that nocturnal physiological hypo-function of the adrenal gland certainly
might be one of the factors favoring precipitation of an attack. Study
of temporal relations between circadian as well as other cyclic control
mechanism and recurrent allergic manifestations, such as asthma, might
help provide a more satisfactory interpretation of certain of the allergic
phenomena and thus perhaps lead to improved methods of treatment."
It has been indicated that the allergic state is one of the constitutional
manifestations of "Hypoadrenocorticism" whether inherited or
acquired. Rackmann followed a number of asthmatic patients for twenty to
thirty years and found some to have two distinct episodes separated by
a long symptom-free interval. The first episodes occurred in the teens
or twenties and these he attributed to allergy or "extrinsic"
causes, i.e. infections or other stressful situations. His interpretation
is that the allergy and the infection are merely exciting causes which
produce asthma in a patient who suffers from a definite constitutional
disease and gives as one theory of explanation, a disturbance of adrenal
function.[63]
In our large series of cases manifesting allergic symptoms, several findings have been constant with modifications, if in addition to the adrenal cortices, other glands are involved. The most important of these general findings may be enumerated as follows:
1. Relative lymphocytosis
2. Eosinophilia
3. Low, flat glucose tolerance curve or reactive hypoglycemia
4. Hypometabolism - low B.M.R. - normal P.B.I, T-3 and RaI uptake
5. Hyponatremia
Hypometabolism has generally been attributed to an atypical hypothyroidism
since the B. M. R usually ranges from minus 10 to as low as minus 26, even
though the P.B.I. is normal. Patients, although asthenic and exhibiting
none of the classical symptoms of myxedema or thyroid dysfunction, were
placed on thyroid medication and often responded with an exacerbation of
their symptoms or showed marked sensitivity to the extract. On the other
hand, minimal doses of proloid (1/4 gr.) stimulated the adrenal-thyroid
axis with gratifying but not necessarily permanent results. If any improvement
occurred, it could be explained an the basis of the response of the thyroid-adrenal
axis. Within the past several years, the advocates of this thyroid hypometabolism
were thrown into consternation when the now common P.B.I., T-3 and RaI
determinations indicated normal thyroid levels.
Again, an explanation had to be forthcoming for the enterprising investigators
who postulated that the fault lay at the "cellular level." Cytomel
(tridiothyronine) was employed, again, with some success, in a few individuals,
since in these particular cases, the thyroid-adrenal axis was, at least,
partially intact. The failures naturally occurred in those individuals
whose adrenals could not stand the further abuse of stimulation from the
thyroid following the employment of the potent fractions of its hormone.
The most that can be said for triodiothyronine, is that its action is rapid
in onset and ceases suddenly when withdrawn. Desiccated thyroid is less
expensive and equally effective if at all indicated but dosage should be
in the range of 1/4 gr.
Returning to Selye's Adaptation Syndrome,[64] the criteria for adrenal
insufficiency are the persistence of the thymus and a relative lymphocytosis.
Most frequently, the allergic patient, unless experiencing an acute episode
of an allergic reaction, shows a relative hymphocytosis and absolute eosinophilia.
Briefly, in 1936 Hans Selye demonstrated by a series of animal experiments
that the organism responds in a "stereotypical" manner to a variety
of widely different factors such as infections, intoxications, trauma,
nervous strain, heat, cold, muscular fatigue, etc. The specific actions
of all these agents are quite different. Their only common feature is that
they place the body in a state of general or systemic stress. The infection
initiating an asthmatic attack, or the contact with an allergen in the
nasopharynx causing symptoms hay fever, or the chemical producing cutaneous
reactions are all stressor agents.
During the stress reaction, all the organs of the body show involutional or degenerative changes while the adrenal cortex actually flourishes. This accounts for a normal or low normal value of steroid determinations when obtained in practice on allergic patients. We now are distinguishing between the effects of adrenal cortical insufficiency and adrenal cortical imbalance. It has been shown that groups of hormones from one of the zones may be normal while the others may be present in deficient or abundant concentrations. This is the alarm reaction or the first stage of the more prolonged general adaptation syndrome, which comprises three distinct stages:
1. Alarm reaction - adaptation has not been acquired
2. Stage of resistance - adaptation is optimal
3. Stage of exhaustion - acquired adaptation is lost again
In the General Adaptation Syndrome the most outstanding features of this stress response are: [64]
1. Adrenocortical enlargement with histological signs of hyperactivity - both hypertrophy and hyperplasia.
2. Thymico-lymphatic involution with concomitant blood changes.
a) Eosinopenia
b) Lymphopenia
c) Polymorphonuclear leukocytosis
3. Gastro-intestinal ulceration
4. Shock or other manifestations of damage. Recent work seems to indicate that the thymus plays an important role in immunological development which does not end with adolescence but persists throughout life.
5. Electrolyte imbalance - actual wasting of sodium
Experimentally it has been shown that thymico-lymphatic involution and
typical blood count changes could be produced by adrenal cortical extracts
even in the absence of the adrenals. Production of these hormones is therefore
considered to be the indirect result of stress. ON the other hand, adrenal
cortical extracts lessen shock and gastrointestinal changes and therefore
these conditions are combated by an adequate adrenocortical response. Additionally,
Selye showed in 1937 that the only procedure which could prevent an adrenocortical
response to stress was hypophysectomy. Stress stimulates the adrenal cortex
through the pituitary trophic hormones, or ACTH. Clinically, most allergic
states have responded well to the adrenal cortical extract, individual
steroids and ACTH.
Pottenger and Pottenger in 1938, were the first to report the effects
of adrenal steroids in allergies using a crude adrenal cortical extract.
The percentage improvement in intractable asthma was very high (85%). These
findings were substantiated by other clinicians using the crude extract.
Since the appearance of the purified extracts of Parke-Davis (Eschatin)
and Upjohn (ACE), the literature is replete with beneficial results. [17,
61]
More recently, of course, the individual steroids, starting with cortisone
and hydrocortisone and going on to the newer products, prednisone and prednisolone,
and finally, hexamethasone, have proved to be effective in anaphylactic
shock, status asthmaticus and other acute allergic conditions. However,
these should not be used because of the severe side effects unless ACE
proves to be ineffectual, which is unlikely. Even topical use on the eye
has proved disastrous as indicated by several recent medical reports. These
substances are used as replacement therapy in a sense, since the patient
has to be given maintence doses. When medication is suspended the symptoms
more often than not return and generally, in a more severe form. Thus,
we may see a simple case of hay fever progress into fulminating asthma.
Our experience has been that previous steroid medication renders the
patient much more difficult to treat successfully with adrenal cortical
extract because the dosage of individual steroids necessary for a favorable
response is above the physiologic level of what the adrenals normally produce.
Hence, even though individual steroids are often miraculous in their immediate
effect, aggravation of the underlying cause is precipitated if continued
for any length of time. Prolonged use not only produces a further disfunction
of the adrenal, but it very often leads to actual atrophy of the gland.
ACTH, likewise, my produce dramatic relief of symptoms but continued
treatment, again, leads to an imbalance of three groups of steroids produced
by the adrenals. In addition, ACTH is a protein and in allergic patients
one always runs the risk of producing anaphylactic shock. ACTH is the specific
tropic hormone for hydrocortisone which will be produced in larger amounts
if the adrenal is capable of response. ACTH is not specific for the mineralosteroids
(aldosterone) although there is some overlapping in the stimulatory effect
of ACTH on the zona glomerulosa as evidence by the production of moon facies,
increase in blood pressure, etc.
The 17-ketosteroids also are indirectly stimulated by ACTH but depend
primarily on the gonadotropic hormones for their elaboration. It is readily
foreseeable, therefore, that the employment of either individual steroids
or ACTH will eventually cause a disruption of the balance of all of the
adrenal cortical hormones.
Why then does ACE have a more beneficial effect than either cortisone
or ACTH. Assume that there is a deficiency of glucocorticoids from the
zona fasciculata. The stressor factor in this case is a pollen or other
antigen which starts in motion the events enumerated for the general nervous
system to produce adrenalin which, in turn, activates the hypothalmus which
through humoral reactive hormones and nervous pathways to the pituitary
causes the latter to secrete ACTH and other tropic hormones. Since the
cells of the adrenal cortex which produce cortisone are deficient, there
occurs a further imbalance with overproduction of mineralsteroids and 17-ketosteroids.
The introduction of the whole adrenal cortical extract supplies a sufficient
amount of the glucosteroids to bring their level to normal and thereby
the body reacts physiologically in neutralizing the antigen through the
release of antibodies from the lymphocytes and small white cells of the
lymph. At the same time, if an overabundance of mineralosteroids is being
produced, the introduction of aldosterone in the extract will lower the
amount being produced through its feedback mechanism. Again, theoretically,
if the adrenal production of 17-ketosteroids is subnormal or normal, the
addition of another small amount is not going to produce any appreciable
effect one way or the other, since it will have no effect upon the lymphocytes
but will further assist in establishing normal balance.
In other words, the introduction of ACE tends to produce a state of
homeostasis which is possible in no other conceivable manner. The intricacies
and interactions of the 32 or more adrenal hormones are infinite since
we know some are antagonistic and others synergistic with one another.
There is an astronomical number of combinations necessary to catalyze the
myriad enzymatic reactions which are going on constantly in order to maintain
homeostasis in the whole organism. Variations in this process account for
the differences exhibited by each patient and treatment must be modified
accordingly.
French K. Hansel, in discussing respiratory allergy from the standpoint
of the otolaryngologists, states that - "In the management of allergy
of the respiratory tract, it is quite impossible to separate, for purposes
of diagnosis and therapy, the upper from the lower types. Nasal allergy
may exist alone or in association with bronchial asthma. Conversely, asthma
rarely exists without some concomitant nasal involvement. When allergy
affects al of the respiratory tract, the process must be considered as
a whole and not as two separate units.[65]
Along these lines, I see patients with indications of hypoadrenocorticism
such as undue fatigue, muscle pains, orthostatic hypotension, all relative
to a fall in blood sugar, who at the same time present signs and symptoms
of what has been diagnosed as sphenoid sinusitis, scintillating scotomata,
nystagmus, and "eye aches." In the treatment of the underlying
adrenal insufficiency, in addition to the restoration of normal physical
activity, the glabellar headaches are relieved. The hyperactive pituitary
in its attempt to stimulate the under-functioning adrenal, becomes hypertrophied
or hyperplastic and cannot be contained within the confines of the sella
turcica without pressure and resulting symptoms. Intravenous injections
of 10 to 20 cc. of ACE relieve this situation by its feedback mechanism
and the glabellar headaches (eye aches), nystagmus, and misdiagnosed sphenoid
sinusitis disappear concomitantly. The severe migraine glabellar headache
is often dramatically relieved by the parenteral injection of about 1,500
i.u. of gonadotropic or anterior pituitary like hormone derived from human
placenta.
It is important to realize that the employment of ACE is not simply
replacement therapy since discontinuation of this treatment does not result
in the immediate return of symptoms. Adequate dosage of this extract will
first of all supply a sufficient amount of lacking hormones to combat the
stressful situation. At the same time, the feedback inhibition of the pituitary
provides a four-hour refractory period in which the faltering cells may
return to normal. When the pituitary inhibitory effect wears off these
cells can function more efficiently usually for about a week at the beginning
of treatment.
A very common condition presenting itself today, especially in women,
is iatrogenic hyponatremia. Almost every pharmaceutical house has joined
the campaign to eliminate NaCl through indiscriminate use of diuretics
or "water pills." The possibility of hypokalemia or hyperkalemia
is often mentioned but the critical wasting of sodium is overlooked and
patients are placed on a low salt diet, with no regard to the physiological
principles.
It is well known that hypoadrenocortics waste sodium, potassium and
chlorides. We have devised an electrolyte clearance test which promises
to be more definitive than any of the present day procedures for the detection
of adrenal insufficiency. A twenty-four hour urinary excretion of the electrolytes
is first determined, then the determination is repeated after a sodium
chloride loading of 15 gm. So far, these tests show an astonishing above
normal increase over the first twenty-four hour specimen. As a result of
these observations, we have instituted, as a standard procedure, the administration
of 10 to 20 gr. NaCl every day of the year, increasing to as much as 70
to 80 gr. on hot or humid days. There has been gratifying alleviation of
the most common complaint, fatigue. For the allergic patient, salt tablets
are far superior to any energizer yet devised. Data on this test are not
complete, put preliminary evidence is most encouraging.
Treatment
These patients are in a state of negative nitrogen balance which is
enhanced by the use of cortisone. Anabolic agents are therefore indicated.
ACE is in itself anabolic. The most effective specific agent we have is
"Durabolin." Mild secondary anemia is a frequent finding. B12
and B6 have been used because of the erythropoietic and adrenal saving
effect. Usually the anisocytosis, poikilocytosis, and microcytic and macrocytic
anemias are alleviated by ACE.
It is clear that adrenal hormones are able to forestall the alarming
signs and symptoms of allergies but the mechanism is little understood.
The high incidence of lymphocytosis in allergic states must have some significance.
It was shown by Daugherry and White that the administration of ACE destroys
the lymphocytes with the release of antibodies.[66]
In our experience scratch or patch-testing is only of academic interest
and so-called desensitization shots seem to be of little or no value.
Androgens induce significant retention of calcium and potassium. In
correlation to this a disproportionate amount of sodium is not retained.
As a matter of fact, some patients increase the amount of sodium excreted.
Therefore, to establish homeostasis even with a deficiency of anabolic
hormones, the entire adrenal cortex spectrum must also be employed including
aldosterone or DOCA to establish electrolyte balance.
Most of the anabolic steroids can cause hepatotoxic changes but when
using them in conjunction with ACE we have never encountered difficulty
on that score. (Fluoxymesterone (Halbestin - Upjohn) is roughly five times
as anabolic and androgenic in its activity as methyltestosterone.) One
gram daily of Ascorbic Acid in divided doses is recommended as the only
oral vitamin supplement. The adrenal cortex reacts properly only in the
presence of adequate Vitamin-C and cholesterol.
As we have seen in Selye's General Adaptation Syndrome, a normal response
of the adrenals is necessary to avoid shock and other factors injurious
to the organism. The release of the cortical hormones has an immediate
action on the lymphocytic system. Almost invariably in allergies we find
a relative lymphocytosis and eosinophilia but ACE reduces the lymphocyte
count and many of the lymph nodes decrease in size or disappear. The lymphocytes,
therefore, must be involved in this stressful situation. Although the role
of the eosinophils is at present unclear the Thorn test is based on the
fact that ACTH or epinephrine reduces the eosinophil count. A drop of 50%
is said to be significant proof of adrenal insufficiency but this is not
an entirely reliable indicator.
The standard explanation for many years regarding the allergic response
is that symptoms of hay fever, asthma and eczema result from the contact
of the allergen with the antibody. Much is left unexplained if one adheres
to this idea. This antibody-antigen reaction is supposed to take place
on the surface of the cell, injuring it and releasing histamine. This would
indicate that treatment be directed toward preventing this reaction when
in reality, the normal individual is constantly protected because of this
reaction, since he has sufficient antibodies to neutralize the antigens
constantly bombarding all tissues. True, there is a release of histamine
in all allergic reactions. Our approach to the neutralization of this reaction
is to use histamine azoprotein (Hapamine). Antibodies against histamine
should alleviate the allergic state, but histamine acts as a haptin and
is not antigenic in itself and must be coupled to a protein to form an
antigenic complex. This was accomplished in 1943 by Gell[67] who was successful
in coupling histamine to despeciated horse serum. Histamine azoprotein
has been used to great advantage in effecting a quicker response to ACE
in asthma, vasomotor or allergic rhinitis, physical allergy (heat, cold,
light), gastrointestinal allergy, contact dermatitis, atrophic eczema,
vertigo, periodic headache, liver extract sensitivity, and infantile eczema.
The allergic individual is one whose adrenals cannot meet the demands
of the stressful antigens and reacts pathologically. Tissues react in a
stereotyped manner to any antigen or injury and histamine is released for
the protection of the organism as a whole. A chain of events follows: The
vegetative nervous system reacts to the histamine and releases hormones
from the adrenal medulla to stimulate the hypothalamus and pituitary which,
in turn, causes the elaboration of the protective hormones from the adrenal
cortex.
We have shown elsewhere that "hypoadrenocorticism" may be
an inherited characteristic with typical physical findings, or normal adrenals
may be injured to produce secondary manifestations. From the above precepts,
the management of the allergic state would involve the prevention of further
damage to the adrenals or assistance in the restoration of the malfunctioning
adrenal cortical cells to normal. This is accomplished by giving adequate
amounts of all the adrenal steroids in the form of an extract which also
helps maintain a normal electrolyte level.
We know that all hypoadrenocortics have faulty carbohydrate metabolism
as revealed by the glucose tolerance test which may show a low, flat curve
or a reactive hypoglycemia. We also know all sugars and starches act as
stressor agents.
Therefore, we consider the elimination of all readily available
carbohydrates from the diet (high protein, moderate fat, minimal carbohydrate)
more essential than local treatment and equally as important as supplying
the needed steroids in their naturally occurring balanced concentration
as found only in the extract.
The storage of carbohydrate is largely under adrenal control. Adrenalectomy
decreases glycogen storage in the liver and muscles, while mineralocorticoids
raise the glycogen concentration, especially in the liver. Adrenalin depletes
the hepatic glycogen reserves, since it transforms glycogen into blood
glucose. There is also a simultaneous diminution of muscle glycogen.
However, after a prolonged fast, and in other conditions, which cause
depletion of hepatic glycogen stores, adrenalin may actually raise The
liver glycogen. This is due to the fact that the lactic acid, formed by
the hormone from muscle glycogen, is reconverted into hepatic glycogen
through the "Cori Cycle." Thus, adrenaline transforms muscle
glycogen into lactic acid and the latter is converted into hepatic glycogen,
which, in turn, is broken down into blood glucose by the same hormone through
the activation of specific enzymes.
The lactic acid content of the blood and muscles tends to diminish after
adrenalectomy, apparently because of decreased lactic acid formation. On
the other hand, adrenalin increases the lactic acid content of the blood
due to the above mentioned conversion of muscle glycogen into lactic acid.
In susceptible individuals abnormal accumulation of lactate in the blood
may produce muscular and emotional symptoms which we have observed for
many years and were recently described by Pitts and McClure of St. Louis.[68]
In cases where there is derangement of the glycogen-lactate-glucose cycle,
a post prandial rise in blood sugar may result in an excess of blood lactate.
This produces a state of anxiety - the "Non-neurotic Anxiety Neurosis."
This is attended by fearfulness, feelings of impending doom, fear of going
insane or fear of a heart attack. The physical symptoms attending such
an episode include shortness of breath, chest discomfort, dissiness, faintness,
shakiness, palpitations, and parathesias. Later, muscular aches may appear
in the calves of the legs, the thighs, and temporal muscles. The last may
present a challenge to the otolaryngologist. However, all the aches are
markedly alleviated by intravenous injections of calcium preferably in
the form of gluconate.
The temporal muscular involvement may be accompanied by a sensation
of fullness in the ears. This latter phenomenon may also be produced by
birth control pills as a result of the fluid retaining propensities of
the progesterone as discussed at your last meeting in 1967.
On June 28, 1968, H.E.W. dispatched a bulletin on the adverse reactions
observed in patients receiving oral contraceptives, citing a significant
association in the development of thrombophlebitis and pulmonary embolism.
An association was also implied, which has neither been confirmed nor refuted,
with serious adverse reactions such as cerebrovascular accidents and neuro-ocular
lesions, e.g. retinal thrombosis and optic neuritis. I have had patients
who prior to my treatment reported many ocular and auricular symptoms particularly
scintillating scotomata. When placed on oral contraceptives given in conjunction
with ACE there have been no adverse side effects because the combination
of steroids in the extract has the capability of correcting most hepatic
conditions. The liver is then able to metabolize or detoxify both the estrogens
and progestins and their precursors.
There are many EENT conditions dependent on the release of histamine
and its subsequent involvement in tissue edema and interactions of antigens
and antibodies. However, I will limit my discussion to only a few of the
more salient conditions encountered most frequently, namely, glaucoma,
Meniere's Syndrome, asthma, and glabellar headaches.
Glaucoma
In the course of consultations during the past several weeks with patients
being treated primarily for hypoadrenocorticism, there have been at least
a score who when first examined had some degree of glaucoma. In almost
all cases, the condition has been arrested or in the earlier cases, appears
to be progressing to a complete remission. I have not attempted to modify
treatment prescribed by the ophthalmologist in any way. The improvement
in the eyes is dependent upon the restoration of normal function of the
total organism together with the focal assistance of the specialist, being
cognizant, however, that the adrenal plays an important role in the recovery.
Dworetzky classifies the allergiec diseases of the eye anatomically.[69]
Extraocular lesions
Acute allergic conjunctivitis
Eczema of the eyelids
Angioedema of the eyelids
Vernal catarrh
Ocular lesions
Cornea
Phlyctenular keratoconjunctivitis
Recurrent marginal ulcers
Uveal tract
Non granulomatous uveitis
Granulomatous uveitis
Sympathetic ophthalmia
Endophthalmitis phacoanaphylactica
Lens - cataract
To this list, of course, we would add glaucoma.
ACTH and corticosteroids have assumed considerable attention but I am
sure you are aware of the devastating side-effects, both systemic and topical
from these agents. Both systemic administration of corticosteroids and
their topical use in the eyes can cause serious, often irreversible, ophthalmic
complications. These include exacerbation of Herpes Simplex Keratitis;
also bacterial and fungal infections of the eyes, posterior subcapsular
cataract, and glaucoma.
Josephson was the first to employ ACE in glaucoma with astonishing improvement
in all cases.[2] He attributed the improvement to the normalization of
the capillary permeability which eliminated edema of the ocular tissues.
There is evidence that glaucoma represents an allergic state in which circulation
through the canal of Schlemn is disrupted. Since all allergies, in my estimation,
stem from adrenal cortical insufficiency it is logical to expect ACE to
be beneficial. Josephson found that the administration of ACE caused a
sharp drop in tension with a remarkable rise in visual acuity in primary
simple glaucoma which had not responded to ordinary treatment. He stated
that ACE offers a test of the secretory function of the eye as well as
acting as a therapeutic agent of remarkable value. He was impressed by
the promptness of response. Within 20 minutes after the administration
of ACE the vision rose from 20/100 plus to 20/30 without correction in
one of his cases.
Complete relief from pain and discomfort has generally been observed
even in cases which have advanced to blindness. ACE therapy usually halts
the drop in vision and reduces cupping of the disc. Injections of ACE (usually
10cc., i.v.) may be required as often as every 3 to 4 days but gradually
the intervals are increased to once weekly, thence bi-weekly, etc. The
patient usually has some other manifestation of allergic diathesis, i.e.
hay fever, conjunctivitis or asthma.
Meniere's Syndrome
Bauer describes Meniere's Disease as characterized by recurrent attacks
of sudden vertigo of the "special" type that passes off after
several minutes or hours, sometimes days.[70] These attacks may be accompanied
by temporary tinnitus and impaired hearing on the affected side. In severe
cases, a widespread disturbance of the autonomic nervous system may occur
with vomiting, abdominal pain or diarrhea. Anatomical studies revealed
the commonly described "endolymphatic" hydrops without any signs
of inflammation or hemorrhage. The similarity and combination of Meniere's
attacks with migraine are highly suggestive of vasomotor origin. Intermittent
labarinthic angioneurotic edema seems to fit best the underlying pathologic
process. Vasomotor imbalance, specific allergy or a chronic disease of
the inner ear are often identified as inciting factors in these patients.
Vasoconstricting or vaso-dilating drugs are capable of producing an attack;
therefore, Bellergal with its ability to neutralize both propensities is
a vital component of the overall regimen recommended for autonomic nervous
system instability together with the rest of the regimen employed for any
allergic condition.
In our experience, Meniere's Syndrome is found only in patients evidencing
an underlying adrenal cortical insufficiency. Therefore, our approach to
diagnosis and treatment lies in the area of allergy. The texts say that
acute symptoms of Meniere's can be brought on by infections and emotional
distress. On this premise alone, one can readily see the connection with
hypoadrenocorticism. Stress, from whatever source, evokes acute symptoms
of the various systems including that of the ear.
Our approach to Meniere's emphasizes evaluation of the carbohydrate
metabolism; study of salt and potassium handling via the electrolyte clearance
test; careful search of the patient's history for other allergic manifestations
such as eczema, hay fever and the like, and for recent infections or emotional
stress.
Treatment consists of elimination of readily absorbed carbohydrates,
increase of salt in the diet (including extra salt in tablet form), frequent
small feedings, and Eschatin (Adrenal Cortical Extract) 10 cc. on a once
a week schedule. Desensitization should be limited simply to injections
of histamine azoprotein, in very small doses initially and gradually increasing
to one cc.
As we feel, Meniere's along with other problems, falls into the group
of symptoms of adrenal cortical insufficiency, treatment of the existing
adrenal cortical pathology effects relief of symptoms and usually eliminates
the entire syndrome.
We are well aware that the texts suggest the elimination of salt because
of its "fluid retaining property". However, these patients are
in a state of negative nitrogen balance and require salt for proper metabolism
of protein, and also, the adrenal cortical insufficiency involves failure
of the zona glomerulosa in handling sodium and excessive amounts are lost
in the urine and perspiration. Increasing salt in these patients improves
the sodium-potassium balance and decreases the production of aldosterone.
It is generally accepted that allergic problems are aggravated by stress
from whatever source, be it physical or emotional. This implicates the
adrenal cortex. In a previous paper, "The Hypoadrenocortical State
and Its Management," 1955, we categorized the hypoadrenocortic according
to symptoms. Dizziness and an uncomfortable feeling in the head are noted
in a very large percentage of the patients. Treatment as described eliminates
these complaints. We should like to point out also that in patients who
show a slightly elevated blood pressure with Meniere's it is our conclusion
that this elevation usually indicates a compensatory action of the zona
glomerulosa resulting from excessive stimulation from the pituitary because
of the failure of the zona fasciculata. Again, treatment of the adrenal
cortical insufficiency effects a reduction in blood pressure without the
use of anti-hypertensive drugs and withdrawal of salt. The anti-hypoglycemic
diet with the Eschatin acts to regulate the entire adrenal cortical function,
suppressing the overactivity of the zona glomerulosa and increasing the
efficiency of the zona fasciculata and zona reticularis.
Meniere's Syndrome then falls into the picture of adrenal cortical insufficiency
and is relieved permanently by adherence to the anti-hypoglycemia diet,
use of salt, and periodic injections of adrenal cortex extract plus any
other hormonal djuvant indicated by deficiency in a target organ. The intricacies
of the hydrops of the vestibular system together with modifications of
treatment - hormonal, dietetic and nervous stabilization - have been amply
described by Dr. Goldman in several articles, the most recent and detailed
of which appeared in 1965.[71]
Asthma, hay fever, and many of the allergic dermatitides are treated
in like manner and respond even after the outmoded desensitization therapy
had failed provided the patient has not been thrown completely out of balance
by previous therapy with individual steroids.
Summary
Our clinical experience and Selye's fundamental research lead us to
the conclusion that a very large number of pathological conditions become
apparent only when bodily defense is "derailed" because the adrenal
cortex is exhausted by excessive stress or the adrenal cortex is inherently
deficient. These conditions can be forestalled or alleviated through supporting
and resting the cortex and reducing internal and external stress. This
can be accomplished with diet and ACE and by stabilizing the autonomic
nervous system and controlling any associated endocrine dyscrasia.
References
1. Sidney Smith: Letter to Dr. Holland, June 1835; FAMILIAR MEDICAL QUOTATIONS, Page 12-13, Edited by Maurice B. Strauss, M.D., Little, Brown, and Company, copyright 1968.
2. E. M. Josephson, M.D.: ADRENAL CORTEX HORMONE IN INTRA-OCULAR TENSION, The Eye, Ears, Nose and Throat Monthly, Vol 13, Page 453, 1935.
3. Sam E. Roberts, M.D.: EXHAUSTION; CAUSES AND TREATEMENT: Published by Rodale Books, Inc. Emmaus, Pennsylvania, 18949, copyright 1967.
4. W.D. Currier, M.D. Pasadena, California 91101: Personal Communication
5. Henkin, R.I. and G.F. Powell: INCREASED SENSITIVITY OF TAST AND SMELL IN CYSTIC FIBROSIS; Science, 138:1107, 1962.
6. Henkin, R.I., J.R. Gill, and F.C. Bartter: STUDY IN TASTE THRESHOLDS IN NORMAL MAN - PATIENT WITH ADRENAL CORTICAL INSUFFICIENCY; The Role of Adrenal Cortical Steroids and of Serum Sodium Concentration; J. Clin. Invest. 42:727-735, 1963.
7. Henkin, R.I. and Solomon, D.H. : SALT-TASTE THRESHOLD IN ADRENAL INSUFFICIENCY IN MAN; J. Clin. Endocr., 22:856, 1962.
8. Tintera, John W., M.D. and Goldman, Herbert B., M.D.: HYPOADRENOCORTICISM IN OTOLARYNGOLOGIC SURGICAL PROCEDURES; New York State Journal of Medicine, Vol. 56, No. 6, March 15, 1956.
9. Goldman, Herbert B., M.D. and Tintera, John W., M.D.: HYPOADRENOCORTICISM IN OTOLARYNGOLOGY:, A.M.A. Archives of Otolaryngology, Vol. 64, pp.381-389, November 1956.
10. Goldman, Herbert B., M.D. and Tintera, John W., M.D.: STRESS AND HYPOADRENOCORTICISM: The Implications in Otolaryngology; Annals of Otology, Rhinology and Laryngology, Vol 67, No. 1, Page 185, March 1958.
11. Goldman, Herbert B., M.D.; HYPOADRENOCORTICISM AND ENDOCRINOLOGIC TREATMENT OF MENIERE'S DISEASE; New York State Journal of Medicine, Vol 62, No.3, Page 37-382, February 1, 1962.
12. Tintera, John W., M.D.: THE HYPOADRENOCORTICAL STATE AND ITS MANAGEMENT; New York State Journal of Medicine. Vol. 55, No. 13, pp.1869-1876, July 1, 1955.
13. Tintera, John W., M.D.: STABILIZING HOMEOSTASIS IN THE RECOVERED ALCOHOLIC THROUGH ENDOCRINE THERAPY: Evaluation of the Hypoglycemia Facotr; Journal of the American Geriatrics Society, Vol. 14, No.2, pp. 126-150, February, 1966.
14. Tintera, John W., M.D.: ENDOCRINE ASPECTS OF SCHIZOPHRENIA: Hypoglycemia of the Hypoadrenocorticism; Journal of Schizophrenia, Vol 1, No. 3, pp. 150-181, 1967.
15. Tintera, John W., M.D., and Lovell, Harold W., M.D.: HYPOADRENOCORTICISM IN ALCOHOLISM AND DRUG ADDICTION: Geriatrics, Vol. 6, No. 1, pp.1-11, January-February, 1951.
16. Carryer, Haddon M. and Miller, Archie, W.: THE OCCURRENCE OF ALLERGIC DISEASES IN PATIENTS WITH CUSHING'S SYNDROME; (Mayo Clinic and Foundation), Journal of Allergy, 29:485-492, November, 1958.
17. Tintera, John W., M.D. and Lovell, Harold W., M.D.: ENDOCRINE TREATMENT OF ALCOHOLISM; Geriatrics, Vol. 4, No. 5, pp. 274-280, September-October, 1949.
18. Tintera, John W., M.D.: OFFICE REHABILITATION OF THE ALCOHOLIC, New York State Journal of Medicine, Vol. 56, No. 25, pp. 3896-3901, December 15, 1956.
19. Panos, T.C., M.D.: ADRENOCORTICAL INSUFFICIENCY IN INFANTS; (University of Texas) Texas State Journal of Medicine, 52:9, January, 1956.
20. McKenna, Robert D.: EMERGENCY TREATMENT OF ADRENOCORTICAL INSUFFICIENCY; J.AM.A., 152:1494, August 8, 1953.
21 Taylor, F.S., and Essig, L.L.: ESCHATIN IN ADRENAL CORTICAL FAILURE; Amer. Jour. Obstet. Gynec., 65:720, April 1953.
22. Loehner, Conrad A., (Salem, Oregon): FURTHER OBSERVATIONS ON THE USE OF ADRENAL CORTEX EXTRACT IN THE PSYCHOTIC AND NON-PSYCHOTIC PATIENT; Endocrinology, Vol. 27, September, 1940.
23. Weille, Francis L. M.D.: HYPOGLYCEMIA IN MENIERE'S DISEASE; (Boston) Arch. Otolaryng., Vol 87, pp. 129-131, May, 1968.
24. Goldzieher, Max A. (Endocrinologist - St. Clare's Hospital, 55 East 86th Street, New York, New York, 10028): THE ADRENAL GLANDS IN HEALTH AND DISEASE: Chapter XIV; Cortical Function in Metabolism, pp. 160-301, F.A. Davis Company, 1944.
25. Soffer, Louis L, M.D. , F.A.C.P., Dorfman, Ralph I., Ph.D., and Gabrilove, J Lester, M.D., F.A.C.P. : THE HUMAN ADRENAL GLAND: Cushing's Syndrome; pp. 506-511, Publ. Lea & Febiger, Philadelphia, Penn., 1961.
26. Venning Eleanor H. M.Sc., Ph.D.: MEDICAL CLINICS OF NORTH AMERICA - CHICAGO NUMBER: ENDOCRINOLOGY: Evaluation of Adrenal Cortical Function in Man; Publ. W.B. Saunders Company, Philadelphia and London, January 1948.
27. ADRENAL CORTEX THERAPY IN PSYCHOSES; Therapeutic Notes, pp. 47, February, 1939.
28. THE ADRENAL HORMONES; Therapeutic Notes, pp. 136-141, (Endocrinology Issue) April, 1935.
29. Werner, August A., M.D., F.A.C.P.: ENDOCRINOLOGY: CLINICAL APPLICATION AND TREATMENT: The Adrenal Cortex; pp. 677-693, pp. 478-484; Publ. Lea & Febiger, Philadelphia, Penn., 1942, Second Edition.
30. Hartman, Frank A., Ph.D., and Brownell, Katharine A., Ph.D.: THE ADRENAL GLAND: Adrenal Cortex and Energy Metabolism; pp. 233-239, Publ. Lea & Febiger, Philadelphia, 1949.
31.Wolf, William, M.D. M.S. Ph.D.: ENDOCRINOLOGY IN MODERN PRACTICE: Adrenal Preparations; pp. 1029-1030, Publ. W.B. Saunders Company, Philadelphia and London, Second Edition, Completely Revised, 1940.
32. Gordon, G.S., M.D., Ph.D. Escamilla, R.F., Goldberg, M.B., and Lisser, H., M.D.: ENDOCRINOLOGY IN CLINICAL PRACTICE - Useful Endocrine Preparations: Adrenal Cortex; pp. 383-385, Publ. The Year Book Publishers, Inc., Chicago, Illinois, 1953.
33. Turner, C. Donnell, Ph.D.: GENERAL ENDOCRINOLOGY - The adrenal Glands: Physiologic Specificity of Cortical Componds; pp. 240-242, Publ. W.B. Saunders Company, Philadelphia and London, 1948.
34. MERCK MANUAL OF DIAGNOSIS AN D THERAPY: Adrenocortical and Related Therapy; 484-491, Publ. Merck & Co., Inc. Rahway, New Jersey, Ninth Edition 1956.
35. Hoffman, Jacob, A.B., M.D.: FEMALE ENDOCRINOLOGY: Including Sections on the Male: Relation of the Adrenal Cortex to the Sexual Sphere; pp. 254-259, Publ. W. B. Saunders Company, Philadelphia, and London, 1944.
36. Swingle, W.W. ; Pfiffner, J.J. ; Vars, H.M.; Bott, P.A., & Parkins, W.M.: Science 77:58, 1933.
37. Thomas, Jr., H.M.: J.A.M.A. 123:264, 1943.
38. Weil, P., & Browne, J.S.L.: Science 90:445, 1939.
39. Sarason, E.. L.: Arch. Int. Med. 71:702, 1943.
40. Thorn, G.W.: J.A.M.A, 123-10, 1944.
41. Greenblatt, R.B.: Office Endocrinology, Charles C. Thomas, Springfield, Illinois, 1945.
42. Cheney, W.C.: J.A.M.A., 139:1077, 1949.
43. Sheldon, D.E.: Am. J. Obst. & Gynec. 49:269, 1945.
44. Williams, R.H.: Clinics 5:775, 1946.
45. Gordon, E.S.; Sevringhaus, E.L., & Stark, M.E.: Endocrinology 22:45, 1938.
46. Reed, A.C.: Am J. Trop. Med. 22:127, 1942.
47. Wolff, W.A.; Rhoads, J.E., & Lee, W.E.: Nebraska M.J. 27:369, 1942.
48. Webb Jr., A.: North Carolina M.J. 3:220, 1942.
49. Rhoads, J.E.; Wolff, W.A., & Lee, W.E.: Ann. Surg. 113:955, 1941.
50. Rich, A.R.: Bull. Johns Hopkins Hosp. 74:1, 1944.
51. Freeman, W.; Melick, J.M., & McClusky, D.K.: Am. J. Obst. & Gynec. 33:618, 1937.
52. Solomon, E.P.: Kentucky M.J. 39:58, 1941.
53. Dorsey, C.W.: Am. J. Obst. & Gynec. 58:1073, 1949.
54. Sapeika, N.: Arch. Int. Med. 82:263, 1948.
55. Perera, G.A.: Bull. New York Acad. Med. 26:75, 1950.
56. Pines, K.L.; Perera, G.A.; Vislocky, K., & Barrows, A.D.: Proc. Soc. Exper. Biol. & Med. 68:286, 1948.
57. Perera, G.A., & Pines, K.L.: Proc. Soc. Exper. Biol. & Med. 71:443, 1949.
58. Goldfarb, A.I., & Berman, S.: Quart. J. Stud. On Alcohol 10:415, 1949.
59. Smith, J.J.: Proceedings of the First Clinical ACTH Conference, The Blakiston Company, Philadelphia, Pa., 1950, pp. 566.
60. Smith, J.: N.Y. State J. Med. 50:1704, 1950.
61. Lapin, Joseph H., M.D.; Stanley F. Goldman, M.D., and Alex Goldman, M.D., New York City: THE CLINICAL USE OF ADRENAL CORTEX HORMONES; N.Y. State J. Med. 43:1964, 1943.
62. Perla, David and Marmorston, Jessie: SUPRARENAL CORTICAL HORMONE AND SALT IN THE TREATMENT OF PNEUMONIA AND OTHER SEVERE INFECTIONS; The Eyes, Ears, Nose and Throat Monthly, Vol. 13, pp. 453, 1935.
63 Rackemann, F.M.: ASTHMA IS A CONSTITUTIONAL DISEASE, J. Allergy 29:535, 1958.
64. Selye, Hans: STRESS, Acta, Inc. Med. Publishers, Montreal, Canada, pp. 82, 1950.
65. Hansel, French K.: COSEASONAL INTRACUTANEOUS TREATMENT OF HAY FEVER, J. Allergy, 12:457, 1941.
66. Daugherty, T.F., and White, A.: INFLUENCE OF HORMONES ON LYMPHOID TISSUE STRUCTURE AND FUNCTION, Endocrinology, 35:1, 1944.
67. Gell, P.G.H., and Benacerraf, B.: DELAYED HYPERSENSITIVITY TO SIMPLY PROTEIN ANTIGENS, Advances Immunol., 1:319-343, 1961.
68. Pitts, Ferris N., Jr. M.D., and McClure, James N., Jr., M.D.: LACTATE METABOLISM IN ANXIETY NEUROSIS, New England J. Med., Vol 277, No. 25, pp. 1329-1336, December 1967.
69. Dworetzky, Murray, M.D. (The Allergy Clinic, N.Y. Hospital) New York City: ALLERGIC DISEASES OF THE EYE, N.Y. State J. Med., Vol. 57, No. 4, pp. 765-769, February 15, 1957.
70. Bauer, Julius, M.D., F.A.C.P.: DIFFERENTIAL DIAGNOSIS OF INTERNAL DISEASES: Clinical Analysis and Synthesis of Symptoms and Signs of Pathophysiologic Basis; Chapter 8: VERTIGO, NAUSEA AND VOMITUS; Meniere's Disease, Page 289; published by Grune & Stratton, Inc., 381 Park Avenue South, New York, New York 10016, Third Revised Edition, 1967.
71. Goldman, Herbert B., M.D.: TREATMENT OF THE HYPOGLYCEMIA OF MENIERE'S SYNDROME, Transactions Indiana Academy Ophthalmology and Otolaryngology, 48:7-25, 1965.